Dear Friends & Family:
Please do not give our children ANYTHING ELSE EVER. Your generosity has reached the point of child abuse.
Thank you,
The Cranky Domestiquette
My kids are required to keep their rooms picked up. I’m not doing this because oh my gosh what will my mother-in-law think! I’m doing this to teach them to take responsibility for themselves, to take good care of their own property, and to have pride in the way they live. When everything is scattered in every direction, pieces get lost, toys get broken, and playing is not as much fun.
My children are 8 and 5 years old, respectively. There is ONLY SO MUCH CRAP that an eight-year-old or a five-year-old can deal with. Why would you want to burden them with the responsibility of more STUFF than they can possibly take care of, so that they are constantly in trouble for not keeping it picked up?
In the interest of not giving every pedophile on the internet a map to my home, I’m not publishing pictures of their rooms & play room. I am, however, about to post a picture of the TRASH that came out of their two bedrooms & the game room. This is just the stuff that was so broken I couldn’t bring myself to even donate it to charity, okay?

Now before you get all “well DUH Dumb-estiquette, we’ve seen the rest of your house!” let me add this: I don’t think it’s fair to ask my kids to keep clutter clean so I keep their rooms pretty well sorted out. The last time I had a giant sort-out in their rooms? LESS THAN THREE MONTHS AGO. This is only three months’ worth of broken toys, papers, magazines, sticker books, and other assorted flotsam.
I didn’t go up there to do this. I went up there to vacuum. I couldn’t even vacuum, it was so bad. So we hit it hard. And this is what we came up with.
If you add up those bags, you’re looking at 172 gallons of storage capacity. The bags that aren’t full got so heavy that I was afraid the bag would tear.
I have some more items hidden away, toys that I don’t think they’ll miss. When I’m not 100% sure, I just hide the toy for 3-6 months and if they still haven’t noticed it’s gone, I get rid of it.
So I’m looking at all this crap, and I am begging you, dear family & friends: STOP. PLEASE STOP. I know you think you’re being generous, but all you’re doing is stressing us out and overwhelming the kids. The next time you are tempted to purchase something for my kids, stop in your tracks, put your wallet away, and come to my house. Pick them up and take them to the park, or riding bikes, or roller skating, or whatever.
Instead of buying them some dumb plastic thing make a memory with them that they can keep forever & that won’t just collect dust in the corner until we finally throw it away.


{ 8 comments }
I have asked this of my family since my first was about a year old. I quickly saw the devastating effects of too much crap. And yes, I say devastating and I mean it. You are so right when you say the crap just stresses everyone out and overwhelms the kids, not to mention the parents. My kids just have to LOOK at a toy and BAM they have, say, 300 of said toy. It’s disgusting.
I have family and friends with houses so full of crap that they can’t open a closet or a drawer without getting accosted. Why? WHY?! I have a friend with 47 pairs of pants. 47. That’s after she got rid of several trash bags of clothes. Some of them have the tags still on them. Imagine her kids rooms. You probably can’t really. Her garage has a car buried under crap. A car. It stresses me out and it isn’t even my freaking house.
Anyway, this letter to your friends and family is poignant and much more meaningful than some may imagine. You are asking them to help you teach your children how to live a lifetime without shit mucking up their space, brain and pocketbook. This is very important indeed. I support you.
P.S. I made a pact with myself that I would only give ‘disappearing gifts’ (food, gift certificate for services, tickets to events, homemade coupons, etc.) for a year. I made it through that year and as a result my gift giving has changed considerably.
AmyAnne´s last blog …Sarcasm, A Great Parenting Tool
Devastating is NOT too strong of a word. When your kids get to the point where they’ll break toys for fun, it’s already out of control.
47 pairs of pants? I have a friend who is working on getting a shopping addiction under control – and your friend sounds like she has a big problem.
I LOVE the disappearing gifts idea! I want to start this with my nieces. Their parents have the same problem we do, though they aren’t attacking it yet (that I know of). I’ll bet they would appreciate this.
Once it has started within a family, it’s hard to shut down. Right now certain family members think I’m the devil, but I hope they will begin to see the profit from it.
Wendy´s last blog …Pare It Down 2009: The Kids’ Rooms
Yeah, when my kids go to birthday parties I am all about giving gifts like Bubble Bath and fun bathtub soaps, etc so that they can be used up right away. Or fun character sheets for their bed. Or a gift card. I completely believe that I should never give a gift that I would not like to get in return and I am with ya 100% on the crap-collection. Luckily, in our house, we move just about every 2-3 years, so the junk gets sorted out and sold or thrown away pretty regularly. But not every 3 months… gees, that’s rough.
Texan Mama´s last blog …Flashback Friday: Did You See Me Today?
We’ve been moving at least that often, too – but unfortunately we have a shopaholic in the family. Okay, more than one. I’m hoping at some point the main purchaser will see how much is going OUT the door and rethink the purchasing.
Unfortunately, she is also cleaning out all her junk & thinks the #1 solution is to give it to US. Noooooo! Goodwill!
Wendy´s last blog …Pare It Down 2009: The Kids’ Rooms
The hardest part for me is that I actually spent money on this stuff (I’m the shopper in our house). I’m doing better and not buying as much. Now I just need to work on the getting rid of.
Jennifer´s last blog …Things I just can’t understand.
Boy, you ARE ruthless. Wish I had that in me, even though I fully get what you are saying and agree that the clutter only adds stress. Guess I need even more therapy (for more underlying issues!).
Wendy´s last blog …When the Two Year Old Discovers the Sink Sprayer
I’m such a bad mom that I make my kids clean their own rooms. Once a year. Like clockwork.
The Mother´s last blog …Hippocrates and the Hodos
Thanks for stopping by. I am with you on this. I do this myself about every 2-3 months. Amazingly, they never run out of toys! Ackkk!!
Comments on this entry are closed.